Hero of Israel or Architect of Catastrophe? A 3 Narratives Investigation
By 3 Narratives News | July 16, 2025
“I was born here, I live here, and I will die here — defending this land.”
— Benjamin Netanyahu, speaking to the Knesset, 2014
The Making of a Warrior
He was the son of a historian and the brother of a fallen hero. He served in Israel’s elite Sayeret Matkal unit, led operations behind enemy lines, and became the country’s youngest-ever Prime Minister. Benjamin Netanyahu, to millions of Israelis, is not just a politician — he is a warrior-statesman, shaped by tragedy and bound by duty.
“I lost my brother in Entebbe. I know the price of war. But I also know the price of weakness.” — Netanyahu, 1996
He entered politics during the chaos of the Second Intifada and rose to prominence, promising security through strength. For decades, his message was unwavering: “The Jewish state will not kneel. Never again.”
To many Israelis, particularly after October 7, 2023, he stood as the last wall between them and annihilation.
But at What Cost?
That wall is now crumbling under legal and moral assault.
On July 16, 2025, judges at the International Criminal Court (ICC) rejected Israel’s request to rescind arrest warrants for Netanyahu and his former Defence Minister, Yoav Gallant. They stand accused of war crimes in Gaza — starvation as a weapon, intentional civilian targeting, and crimes against humanity.
“The warrants remain active until the court completes its jurisdictional review.” — ICC Press Office
At the same time, humanitarian groups reported that an Israeli-run aid hub saw 20 Palestinians trampled to death, followed by 54 killed in retaliatory airstrikes. Gaza’s Health Ministry says over 17,000 children have died since the war began.
Meanwhile, Israel’s air force bombed Damascus and Sweida in Syria, saying it was necessary to protect the Druze minority. Critics say the attacks were reckless, bordering on indiscriminate escalation.
The same man once hailed as Israel’s protector now faces international indictment, domestic unrest, and growing comparisons to some of history’s darkest leaders.
A Split-Screen Reality
“Netanyahu is the most consequential leader in modern Israeli history. He is defending not just borders, but the Jewish future.”
— Mike Huckabee, July 2025, Tel Aviv courthouse
“This is a criminal gang. Netanyahu is committing ethnic cleansing.”
— Ehud Olmert, former Israeli Prime Minister, July 2025
The contradictions are stark.
One narrative sees Netanyahu as the shield of a people surrounded by enemies — a bulwark against Iranian proxies, Islamist terror, and Western cowardice.
The other sees him as an opportunist who used legitimate fears to justify illegitimate war — a man who weaponized tragedy, choked aid routes, and bombed indiscriminately, creating what human rights lawyers now call a “model case for prosecution.”
“At least 875 people have died just trying to reach food. This is not collateral damage. This is manufactured suffering.”
— UN Relief Chief, July 2025
Gaza: Between Starvation and Sovereignty
According to multiple UN reports:
- 875 aid-seekers have died in chaotic distribution events since April
- 54 civilians were killed in a single night of Israeli bombing following an aid incident
- Nearly 1 in 4 children in Gaza are now acutely malnourished
- Tens of thousands of homes have been destroyed
“It is clear that hunger is being used as a weapon of war.” — ICC Prosecutor Karim Khan
Israel denies these accusations, pointing to Hamas’ use of human shields and the need to neutralize “terror tunnels.” But aid organizations and rights monitors argue the scale of devastation far exceeds military necessity.
Syria: A New Front, or a Final Straw?
The airstrikes in Syria—targeting sites near Damascus and Sweida—were framed by Netanyahu’s cabinet as a humanitarian intervention to protect the Druze minority from Alawite militia reprisals.
“We acted decisively to prevent another massacre. If that makes us war criminals, then history will judge us wrongly.” — Netanyahu, July 15
But international observers say no multilateral request was made. The strikes appeared to violate Syrian sovereignty and risk regional escalation.
“The optics of defending civilians in Syria while starving them in Gaza is morally indefensible.” — Middle East Human Rights Watch
Two Narratives — Equally Powerful
The Defender’s Perspective
- October 7 changed everything. Hamas’ attack left 1,400 dead, including children.
- Israel’s enemies—Hezbollah, Iran, even the UN—want its destruction.
- Netanyahu, flawed or not, is a wartime leader in wartime conditions.
- The ICC’s jurisdiction is questionable, and international hypocrisy abounds.
“The world has a short memory. We have a long border.” — Israeli Security Adviser
The Prosecutor’s Perspective
- Netanyahu’s government has crossed moral and legal lines.
- Gaza is in ruins; starvation and airstrikes are documented and deliberate.
- The humanitarian toll is historic and unjustifiable.
- The ICC, though imperfect, is the only mechanism for accountability.
“Even during war, there are rules. Israel broke them.” — Human Rights Watch
Reader’s Judgment
We stand, as readers and global citizens, at a moment of profound discomfort.
Netanyahu’s life began in sacrifice and service. He buried a brother. He fought on the front lines. He endured years of hatred from enemies and dissent from within. For many, he is the only leader with the strength to secure Israel’s survival.
But today, his policies—once called protective—are now called criminal. Is he a Man waging war for survival at the expense of Children’s Lives amongst his own people’s lives? Once celebrated for fortitude, he is now accused of Crimes Against Humanity. He is still prime minister, still defiant, but under arrest, in the court of global opinion.
You, the reader, must now ask:
- Can one be both protector and persecutor?
- When does security become cruelty?
- Is the ICC’s warrant a defence of international law, or an attack on sovereignty?
Closing Thought
History rarely writes in absolutes. But it often remembers those who acted as if it did.
Netanyahu once warned the world to “never forget.” Now, the world must decide what it will remember of him.
